Now that the discussion around the ‘multiculturalism has failed’ speech by David Cameron at the Munich Security Conference has calmed a little I felt it was an appropriate time to have a sensible debate about the issue. Having worked in the UK’s multicultural marketing industry for over 23 years, I feel that I’m in a very good position to provide a little insight.
In the Speech Mr Cameron suggested that the British state, in era gone by had actively encouraged different cultures, communities and ethnic groups to live separate lives. In my vast experience I find this quite hard to believe. The Government could be accused of not doing enough to integrate new migrants into British society, but I don’t believe they are actively encouraging this.
As an Iraqi migrant myself who has lived in the UK for over 28 years, I know what the experience of moving to a new country feels like. I was lucky that I came here to study and through the university experience was able to integrate better because I could speak the language and was in an institution where it was difficult to avoid meeting local students and immersing into the local culture.
If we’re accusing new migrants of coming to UK and not making the effort to integrate better into wider society, then maybe we should look at a few case studies of British emigrants.
Let’s say Spain for example. British emigrants to Spain are caricatured (ITV’s Benidorm), as moving to the country for a quieter life and lots of Sun Sea and sangria. However, a large number of Brits moving to the country tend to live amongst other Brits and even create a mini industry for themselves flogging British food and goods and consequently not learning the language. Does the scenario sound familiar?
Let’s move a little further afield. Dubai. Now, Brits, and you could even argue migrants to Dubai from other countries to, move there for the lifestyle and work opportunities. But from the many accounts of local people, Brits and migrants from other countries tend to live a very exclusive life amongst themselves, and not really integrated better with the locals.
The point I’m making is that a new migrant moving to a new country always looks for familiarity and a little comfort to settle them in. It’s not exclusive to the UK or Europe; it’s an instinctive human reaction for comfort and survival. That’s why you have new migrants moving to areas around the UK where they find other people who are either from their mother countries and know the newcomer’s language and culture. Australians and South African for example who have moved the UK, don’t really have the language barriers that other migrants may have but how do you then explain the high number of Aussies and Saffas living in South West i.e. Wimbledon and Putney?
My fear is that every time there is a debate about multiculturalism, it always harbours undertones of ethnicity, terrorism, and fear. Mixing the debate does generate headlines and even appeases some right wing groups that the Government is seen to be doing something but it doesn’t address any issues and, as is the case now, brushed under the carpet until the next time a speech on the issue is needed.
I don’t believe multiculturalism has failed. I think Government policy has failed because as with some of the examples above, migrants who come to this country, and to any country for that matter, want to make a living and add to that countries economy, But if the local culture is hostile and they have no opportunities to integrate better into wider society, then how does Mr Cameron expect this to work?
In my experience multiculturalism is working. We have multi-million pound businesses and industries, which have come about as a result of immigration. New communities have added to the culture, art, make-up of local communities from sport, music, food to events and celebrations that have added to the wider publics’ awareness of international cultures. That can only be beneficial in a global multicultural world, and Britain, with its experience should be leading the way!
Saad Saraf
CEO
Saad has been the ultimate driving force and the visionary behind the development and growth of multicultural marketing. His agency Mediareach Advertising has helped hundreds of ethnic and companies communicate effectively with the UK’s and Europe diverse customers.
Saad Saraf is highly regarded in the advertising industry and is a council member of the IPA and head of the diversity group.
He has written a number of papers and the recent report for the IPA (Multicultural Britain in March 2010).
www.mediareach.co.uk
www.mediareachstar.com
www.salaamcommunications.com
0.000000
0.000000